ICT Integrated Lesson Plan

 

 ICT Lessons

Author

Brad J Boudreau

Title

Using Comic Life to Illustrate the 4 P's of Marketing

Grade Level

12

Subject Area

Entrepreneurship

Overview of unit/lessons/activities (assumptions of prior knowledge/learning)

Prior Knowledge: Three Functions of a Marketing Strategy

Lesson: Using Comic Life, choose pictures and create text to illustrate the 4 P's of Marketing.

Unit 3: Moving Into Action

Correlations to ICT and curriculum outcom

* Draft Document 2003* ENT 12...no numerical notation until it is approved by DOE. No PDF version available ( as of April , 08).

1. Opportunity Knocks: Students will be expected to generate ideas and Identify entrepreneurial activities.

       a) gather information, evaluate entrepreneurial ideas for a business or venture, and make informed decisions,

       b) select, evaluate, and defend appropriate research methods for assessing the feasibility of a business venture

2. Making Connections: SWBE to demonstrate a basic understanding of the role of Entrepreneurship in local, national, and international economies

       a) identify the potential for local businesses or ventures in the global market.

       b) identify trends that influence the marketplace

3. Technology and Entrepreneurship: SWBE to demonstrate an understanding of the role of technology and its application to entrepreneurship.

      a) demonstrate the ability to use technology in an entrepreneurial activity

      b) use the Internet for business purposes

4. Putting it All Together: SWBE to demonstrate the personal qualities and characteristics of successful entrepreneurs.

       a) apply teamwork skills to solve a business problem

       b) demonstrate collaboration and consultation with others in entrepreneurial activities

Basic Operations and Concepts 
By the end of grade 12, students will be expected to
BOC 12.1 (relates to 9.1 – 9.4) use a wide variety of technology, demonstrate a clear understanding of technological applications, and consistently apply appropriate technology to solve curriculum problems
BOC 12.2 (relates to 9.5) demonstrate an ability to assess the application of technology to solve problems, particularly to evaluate significant effects which estimations, program flaws and human error have on any given solution
Social, Ethical, and Human Issues 
By the end of grade 12, students will be expected to
SEHI 12.1 (relates to 9.1 – 9.4) behave ethically and with accuracy as they generate and distribute information about themselves, others, and curriculum topics under study
SEHI 12.4 (relates to 9.2 – 9.4) demonstrate habits of perception, analysis, judgment and selectivity as they contribute to society through the discerning and critical use and creation of information resources and technology
SEHI 12.5 (relates to 9.3, 9.4) act responsibly when faced with ethical issues that arise from their use of information and ICT and perspectives
Productivity 
By the end of grade 12, students will be expected to
PTS 12.5 (relates to PTS 9.6 and RPSD 9.2) create electronic charts, tables and graphs; and design, create, and manipulate spread sheets and databases, as part of the process of collecting, analyzing, and displaying data independently
Communication
By the end of grade 12, students will be expected to
CT 12.1 (relates to 9.1) use language, in a range of aural, print, media and electronic forms to explore and express their perceptions, feelings, ideas and attitudes; refine their thinking; and interact, negotiate, and collaborate with others in order to build their understanding
CT 12.2 (relates to 9.1, 9.2) critically apply technological skills in a range of electronic, visual, and print media for formal and informal communication
CT 12.3 (relates to 9.1) design and create electronic documents to accomplish curricular tasks
CT 12.6 (relates to 9.3) assess the value and application of information and communication technology in personal and career-related pursuits
Research, Problem Solving, and Decision Making 
By the end of grade12, students will be expected to
RPSD 12.1 (relates to 9.1) select appropriate devices and software to collect data, solve problems and note patterns; to make logical decisions and draw conclusions; and to present results, with general supervision
RPSD 12.2 (relates to 9.4) identify, evaluate, and compare the quality, congruencies, discrepancies, omissions, biases, and perspectives of information content of print, media, and electronic resources
RPSD 12.3 (relates to 9.3 – 9.8) evaluate and organize ideas and information from a wide range of media and a variety of sources to meet their curriculum needs efficiently and independently
RPSD 12.4 (relates to 9.7) identify the strengths and limitations of different approaches to research, and select those approaches which efficiently meet their learning needs 
RPSD 12.5 (relates to 9.4 –9.8) contribute to the development of criteria for selecting a research topic, and, based on those criteria, define and complete a research task efficiently

 

Projected timeline for preparation and for carrying out activities

 

One class period for activity/lesson.

Prep work. Need a bank of copyright cleared images for inclusion into Comic Life.

Equipment Requirements: (computers, software, etc)

 

IEIE laptops with Comic Life installed. Computer labs may not have Comic Life.

 

Teaching materials provided (Blacklines, worksheets, templates, teacher materials)

 

Resources available for teacher/student use (websites, references, etc)

 

www.business.nelson.com

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drainage_patterns excellent explanation of the drainage systems

edit] Types of drainage system (geomorphology)

Drainage systems fall into one of several categories, depending on the topography and geology of the land:

Dendritic drainage pattern.
Dendritic drainage pattern.
Parallel drainage pattern.
Parallel drainage pattern.
Trellis drainage pattern.
Trellis drainage pattern.

[edit] Dendritic drainage system

Dendritic drainage systems are the most common form of drainage system. The term dendritic comes from the Greek word "dendron", meaning tree, due to the resemblance of the system to a tree. In a dendritic system there is one main river (like the trunk of a tree), which is joined and formed by many smaller tributary rivers. They develop where the river channel follows the slope of the terrain. Dendritic systems form in V-shaped valleys; as a result, the rock types must be impervious and non-porous.[1]

[edit] Parallel drainage system

A parallel drainage system is a pattern of rivers caused by steep slopes with some relief. Because of the steep slopes, the streams are swift and straight, with very few tributaries, and all flow in the same direction. This system forms on uniformly sloping surfaces, for example, rivers flowing southeast from the Aberdare Mountains in Kenya.

[edit] Trellis drainage system

Trellis systems form in areas of alternating geology, particularly chalk and clay. The main river (the consequent) flows straight down hill. Subsequent streams develop perpendicular to the consequent along softer rock and erode it away, forming vales. The consequent river then cuts through the escarpments of harder rock. Obsequent streams flow down the dip slope of the escarpments to join the subsequent streams.

Rectangular drainage pattern.
Rectangular drainage pattern.
Radial drainage pattern.
Radial drainage pattern.
Deranged drainage pattern.
Deranged drainage pattern.

[edit] Rectangular drainage system

This develops on a strongly jointed rocky terrain. The rectangular drainage pattern is found in regions that have undergone faulting. Streams follow the path of least resistance and thus are concentrated in places where exposed rock is the weakest. Movement of the surface due to faulting off-sets the direction of the stream. As a result, the tributary streams make shape bends and enter the main stream at high angles.

[edit] Radial drainage system

Rivers radiate outwards from a central point, e.g. a volcanic cone or from a mountain range batholith

[edit] Deranged drainage system

A deranged drainage system is a drainage system in watersheds where there is no coherent pattern to the rivers and lakes. It happens in areas where there has been much geological disruption. The classic example is the Canadian Shield. During the last ice age, the topsoil was scraped off, leaving mostly bare rock. The melting of the glaciers left land with many irregularities of elevation, and a great deal of water to collect in the low points, explaining the large number of lakes which are found in Canada. The watersheds are young and are still "sorting themselves out". Eventually the system will stabilize.[citation needed]

 

Detailed instructions for each activity or lesson (teacher notes, activity information, learning strategies, teacher role, student roles)

 

Students will be introduced to the 4 P's of marketing, either through homework reading of textbook (pg 181)or PowerPoint.

Students will be expected to use Comic Life to create a 4 page document (one page for each P).

Students will be in groups of 2 if 15 laptops are available, individual if 30 laptops are available.

 

 

Student products expected

4 page Comic Life document to be emailed to teacher.

Samples (include teacher notes, assessment information, student work if available)

 

Logistics (organization, grouping, management issues, access to technology)

 

Issues of availability, if no IEIE computers are available this lesson will not be possible

Assessment information (e.g., rubrics for products and/or process)

http://www.aac.ab.ca/public/sampler.doc

excellent site for assessment rubrics from Alberta

Effective Rubric Sampler

 

The sampler is a potpourri of rubrics based on a variety of criteria applicable to many subject areas including ICT, Language Arts, Mathematics, Science and Social Studies. The rubric samples originate from performance assessments developed by teachers working with the Alberta Assessment Consortium (AAC).

 

The language used within each rubric needs to be understandable to students. Student involvement in discussing, designing, selecting or modifying criteria and rubric language is essential in order to realize the learning and assessment potential of performance assessments and rubrics.

 

The sampler is a resource for developing your own performance assessments and rubrics.

 

                         

              Level

 

 

Criteria

 

4

Excellent

 

3

Proficient

 

2

Adequate

 

1

Limited *

 

Insufficient / Blank *

 

Identifies and supports favorite part

(Add outcome code with each criteria)

 

Identifies precisely what was liked and includes significant supporting evidence

Identifies what was liked and includes supporting evidence

Identifies what was liked and includes some supporting evidence

Identifies what was liked with little, if any supporting evidence

No score is awarded because there is insufficient evidence of student performance based on the requirements of the assessment task.

 

 

 

Expresses feelings

 

Expresses feelings eloquently and with conviction

 

Expresses feelings clearly

Expresses feelings incompletely

Expresses few, if any feelings

 

 

Summarizes main idea

 

Summarizes main idea thoroughly and insightfully

Summarizes main idea

Summarizes main idea partially

 

Unable to summarize main idea

 

 

 

 

 

Illustrates opinions

 

 

 

Chooses visuals and sounds that effectively and completely support opinions

 

Chooses visuals and sounds that support opinions

Chooses visuals and sounds that provide incomplete support for opinions

Chooses visuals and sounds that offer little, or no support for opinions

 

 

 

Collects data

 

 

Collects relevant data and enters it accurately on the tally sheet

Collects data and completes tally sheet correctly

Collects data, but tally sheet contains some errors

Collects little data and produces an incomplete tally sheet

 

 

 

 

Displays data

 

 

Accurately displays data using rank ordering and skillful organization

Accurately displays data using rank ordering

Displays data using rank ordering with some errors

Displays data unclearly or in a confusing way

 

 

 

 

Makes a recommendation

 

 

Uses data to make an insightful, creative recommendation about preferences

 

 

Uses data to make a recommendation about preferences

Uses data to make a recommendation about preferences that are partially supported by the data

 

Makes a recommendation about preferences that are not based on the data

 

 

Presents data

 

Uses technology to effectively display data that is organized and easy to interpret

 

Uses technology to display data that is accurate and clear

Uses technology to display compiled data, but presentation may be muddled or contain errors

Uses technology to present incomplete data that does little to assist in solving the problem

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Draws conclusions

 

 Uses technology to create a menu that represents a thoughtful interpretation of the data

 

 Uses technology to create a menu that represents an accurate interpretation of the data

 Uses technology to create a menu that partially reflects the data

 Uses technology to create a menu that does not reflect the data

 

 

 

 

Supports conclusions

 

 

Uses data to provide convincing support for conclusions

Uses data to support conclusions

Uses data to provide partial support for conclusions

Draws conclusions that are not related to data

 

 

Organizes ideas to emphasize key points

 

Key points are insightful, memorable, and clearly organized

Key points are logical, credible, and well organized

Key points are generally organized

Key points are vague

 

 

 
Selects visuals to inform and engage

 

Selects visuals that are vivid and engaging

Selects visuals that are appealing and appropriate

Selects visuals that are generally appropriate

Visuals lack appeal

 

 

Selects vocabulary to enhance writing

 

Selects words that are vivid and enhance meaning

Selects words that are appealing and support meaning

Selects words that are predictable and partially support meaning

Word selection is basic and does little to support meaning

 

 

 

Identifies main idea

 

Main idea is specific and insightful

Main idea is meaningful and relevant

Main idea is general

Main idea is vague

 

 

 

 

Creates concept map

 

 

Displays in-depth, precise details that indicate main idea

Displays clear and correct details that indicate main idea

Displays partially correct details that indicate main idea

Displays incorrect or sketchy details that indicate main idea

 

 

Provides supporting evidence

 

 

Supports main idea skillfully with relevant information from own experience and/or text

Demonstrates connection between text and/or own experience thoughtfully

Shows credible relationship of main idea to text and/or own experience

Makes vague connection between main idea and text and/or own experience

 

 

Gathers effective resources

 

Supporting details are insightful and highly relevant to task

Supporting details are appropriate and relevant to task

Supporting details are relevant to topic but general

Supporting details are minimal and unspecific

 

 

 

 

Organizes information

 

 

Organization of information is astute and categories are distinct and useful

Organization of information is logical and categories are clear and useful

Organization of information is partial and categories are general

Organization of information is ineffective and haphazard

 

 

Designs brochure

 

 

Design of brochure is engaging and memorable

Design of brochure is effective and interesting

Design of brochure is appropriate but simplistic

Design of brochure is basic and lacks impact

 

 

Analyses character

 

 

Provides insightful and perceptive examples to develop an in-depth analysis of the character in terms of behaviour, motivation and plausibility, and thematic connection

 

Provides thoughtful examples to develop a detailed analysis of the character in terms of behaviour, motivation and plausibility, and thematic connection

Identifies predictable examples to develop a partial analysis of the character in terms of behaviour, motivation and plausibility, and thematic connection

Sketchy and ineffective examples are used to develop an analysis of the character in terms of behaviour, motivation and plausibility, and thematic connection

 

 

Presents orally

 

 

Presentation is perceptive and captivates the audience

 

Presentation is thoughtful and engages the audience

Presentation is simplistic and only partially connects with the audience

Presentation is vague and lacks audience appeal

 

 

Provides insights

 

Presents a perceptive and astute understanding of how the character profile project interconnects with self

 

Presents an appropriate and clear understanding of how the character profile project interconnects with self

Presents a general understanding of how the character profile project interconnects with self

Demonstrates minimal understanding of how the character profile project interconnects with self

 

 

Présente son choix de métier

 

Presentation vivante avec raisons claires et bien soutenues

Présentation claire avec raisons valables

Présentation prévisible avec raisons supperficielles

Présentation minimale avec peu de raisons soutenues

L’évaluation du rendement de l’apprenant n’a pas été possible ŕ cause de l’absence d’un produit ou de l’insuffisance des réponses.

 

Décrit avec un vocabulaire approprié

 

Utilise un vocabulaire pertinent en phrases complčtes

 

 

Utilise un vocabulaire approprié en phrases fonctionnelles

Utilise un vocabulaire général en phrases simples

Utilise un vocabulaire limité en phrases incomplčtes

 

 

Explique comment ce métier aide la communauté

Articule clairement le lien entre le métier et les besoins de la communauté

Démontre le lien entre le métier et les besoins de la communauté

Identifie le lien entre le métier et les besoins de la communauté

Peu de connections entre le métier et les besoins de la communauté

 

 

Formule la question

 

Question exacte avec choix valables

Question claire avec choix appropriés

Question générale avec choix partiellement reliés

Question inexacte avec choix sans rapport

 

 

Choisis la méthode de prise de données

La méthode utilisée est efficace

 

La méthode utilisée est logique

La méthode utilisée est suffisante

La méthode utilisée est faible

 

 

Partage ses trouvailles

 

Présentation clairement basée sur son graphique

 

Présentation raisonnablement basée sur son graphique

Présentation partiellement basée sur son graphique

Présentation faiblement basée sur son graphique

 

 

Construit un instrument de musique

Instrument original et fonctionnel

Instrument approprié et utilisable

Instrument simpliste ŕ fonction partielle

Instrument mal conçu et inutilisable

 

 

Produire des sons variés

Produit des sons exceptionnels

 

 

Produit des sons clairs

Produit des sons adéquats

Produit des sons minimaux

 

 

Présente son choix de métiers

 

Présentation complčte et bien organisée

Présentation détaillée et organisée

Présentation générale

Présentation peu précise

 

 

Décris son métier

 

Vocabulaire et structures riches et précises

 

Vocabulaire et structures pertinents

 

Vocabulaire et structures simples mais appropriés

 

Vocabulaire et structures minimals peu reliés au sujet

 

 

 

Explique comment ce métier aide la communauté

L’élčve soutient son point complčtement

L’élčve soutient son point raisonnablement

L’élčve soutient son point partiellement

L’élčve soutient son point faiblement

 

 

Determines volume of right rectangular prism

 

Diagram of box is clearly labeled and fulfills all the stated requirements correctly calculated volume.

Diagram of box is clearly labeled and fulfills the requirements for a calculated volume that contains minor errors.

Diagram of box only partially fulfills requirements related to volume.

Diagram demonstrates little understanding of the concept of volume.

 

 

 

Determines the surface area of right rectangular prisms

 

Uses an efficient an effective strategy to correctly determine the surface area of the chocolate box.

Uses an appropriate strategy to determine the surface area of chocolate box with minor errors in calculation.

Strategy chosen demonstrates partial understanding of surface area with obvious errors in calculation.

Strategy chosen demonstrates little understanding of surface area with significant errors in calculation.

 

 

Communicate ideas and justifies choices

 

Provides clear and compelling reasons that support design choice

Provides plausible reasons that support design choice

Provides reasons with minimal support for design choice

Lists reasons that do not support for design choice.

 

 

Clarifies and shapes ideas in a group

 

Clarifies and shapes understanding through effective and extensive collaboration with others

Clarifies and shapes understanding through collaboration with others

Shares understanding with others

Shares little or no understanding with others

 

 

 

Participates in and contributes to group work

 

 

Contributes enthusiastically and invites suggestions from other group members to develop an effective advertising strategy

 

 

Contributes to group and accepts others’ ideas to develop an effective advertising strategy

Contributes to group to develop an advertising strategy

Participates only when encouraged that does not develop an effective advertising strategy

 

 

Creates advertisements

 

 

Produces a wide variety of advertisements that clearly and persuasively sell the product based on the advertising strategy

 

Produces a range of advertisements that sell the product based on the advertising strategy

Produces similar advertisements to sell the product based on the advertising strategy

 

Produces advertisements that are lacking in persuasion and originality and may not be based on the advertising strategy

 

 

 

 

Communicates key ideas and information

 

 

 

Communicates key ideas and information convincingly throughout the presentation that considers purpose and audience

 

Communicates ideas and information effectively throughout the presentation that considers purpose and audience

Communicates some ideas and information during the presentation that may consider both purpose and audience

Communicates few ideas during the presentation that does little to consider both purpose and audience

 

 

 

Accesses and retrieves information

 

Effectively and efficiently accesses and retrieves relevant information from a variety of electronic sources

Accesses and retrieves relevant information from a range of electronic sources

Accesses and retrieves some relevant information from provided electronic sources

Accesses, but has difficulty retrieving relevant information from provided electronic sources

 

 

 

Creates folder and organizes information

 

 

Organizes information effectively and efficiently in an electronic folder enabling easy access by group members.

 

Organizes information in an electronic folder enabling fairly efficient access by group members.

Information is somewhat organized within an electronic folder making it awkward for group members to access

Information is disorganized within an electronic folder making it difficult for group members to access

 

 

Creates a multimedia presentation

 

Designs a multimedia presentation that skillfully features a variety of visual images, sounds and animated images that persuasively sells the product to a particular audience

 

Designs a multimedia presentation that features meaningful visual images, sounds or animated images to sell the product to a particular audience

Designs a multimedia presentation that uses some visual images, sounds or animated images to sell the product to a particular audience

Designs a multimedia presentation that uses few, if any visual images, sounds or animated images to sell the product and may not consider audience

 

 

 

Composes story

 

Composes original and compelling story with rich supporting details

Composes original story with supporting details

Composes simple and predictable story with few supporting details

Composes incomplete, uninteresting or disjointed story

 

 

Uses conventions

 

Spelling, grammar, capitalization and punctuation is accurate and enhances impact of story; errors are hardly noticeable

Spelling, grammar, capitalization and punctuation has few errors and do not interfere with writer’s intended meaning

Spelling, grammar, capitalization and punctuation applications are inconsistent and interfere with writer’s intended meaning

Spelling, grammar, capitalization and punctuation errors are evident and interfere significantly with writer’s intended meaning

 

 

Presents story

 

 

Presents story that engages and holds the interest of the audience

 

Presents story that communicates to audience

Presents story that communicates to audience, but does not sustain interest throughout

Presents story that does not suit the needs or interests of the audience

 

 

Clarifies problem

 

Shows an insightful understanding of the problem by making pertinent predictions that can be researched and tested

 

Shows an understanding of the problem by making reasonable predictions that can be researched and tested

Shows a partial understanding of the problem by making predictions that are may be difficult to research or test

Shows minimal understanding of problem by making predictions that are not testable

 

 

 

Designs and carries out a plan

 

 

Sets up and carries out a procedure designed to provide complete, relevant and accurate data and a model

 

Sets up and carries out a procedure designed to provide accurate data and a model

Sets up and carries out a procedure that provides incomplete, data and a workable model

 

Sets up and carries out a procedure that provides little data and an unworkable model

 

 

 

Conducts experiments

 

 

 

Conducts exhaustive trials to provide complete, valid and accurate data about the effects of the adaptations

 

Conducts sufficient trials to be considered a fair test and provides relevant and accurate data about the effects of the adaptations

Conducts simple tests that provide incomplete data about the effects of the adaptations

Conducts tests that provide little data about adaptations

 

 

 

Identifies alternatives and evaluates effects

 

 

 

Uses data and observations to provide a clear and logical explanation of which design characteristic adaptations led to peak performance

 

Uses data and observations to provide a reasonable explanation of which design characteristic adaptations led to peak performance

Uses data and observations to provide some support for choice of design characteristic adaptations that led to peak performance

Choice of design characteristic adaptations is not based on data or observations

 

 

Communicates recommendation

 

Uses technology effectively to create a highly visual and practical recommendation that is persuasive and engages the audience

 

Uses technology to create a readable recommendation with visuals that appeal to the audience

Uses technology to create a recommendation that conveys information in a straight forward manner with little audience appeal

 

Uses technology to create a recommendation that provides little, if any information about forestry management and lacks audience appeal

 

 

Solves problem

 

 

 

Insightfully, accurately and effectively provides solution to forestry management problem by sorting, organizing and classifying data, using a technology tool(s)

Provides solution to forestry management problem by sorting, organizing and classifying data, using a technology tool(s)

Provides partial solution to forestry management problem by sorting, organizing and classifying data, using a technology tool(s)

Provides an incomplete or indefensible solution to solve forestry management problem by sorting, organizing and classifying data, using a technology tool(s)

 

 

Demonstrates understanding

 

 

Demonstrates a thorough and insightful understanding of the chosen theme and comprehensively explains historical significance using relevant facts

Demonstrates a clear understanding of the chosen theme and explains historical significance using relevant facts

Demonstrates some understanding of the chosen theme and explains historical significance using generalities

Demonstrates little, or no understanding of the chosen theme with an unclear explanation of historical significance

 

 

Locates information based on research questions

 

Selects and organizes specific, comprehensive information related to the theme

Selects and organizes information related to the theme

Selects and organizes information partially related to the theme

Selects irrelevant or inaccurate information related to the theme

 

 

Synthesizes information

 

 

Synthesizes information, determines patterns and links ideas to effectively present the theme

 

Synthesizes information, determines patterns and links ideas to present the theme

Partially synthesizes information, determines patterns and links ideas to present the theme

Partially synthesizes information to present an incomplete theme

 

 

Builds chemical models

 

Constructs models that effectively depict structures and scientific principles accurately

 

Constructs models that depict structures and scientific principles

Constructs models that partially depict structures and may lack scientific accuracy

Constructs models that have little scientific accuracy

 

 

Explains organic chemical reactions

 

 

Provides in-depth scientific descriptions of chemical processes including complete and accurate chemical equations

 

Provides scientific descriptions of chemical processes including accurate chemical equations

Provides partial scientific descriptions of chemical processes with some chemical equations

Provides scientifically incorrect descriptions of the chemical processes; equations, if included, contain many errors

 

 

Evaluates environmental impact

 

Presents a comprehensive list of various sides of the issue that represent important possible alternatives in detail and makes a recommendation that is effectively supported by an insightful analysis of the issues

 

Identifies various sides of the issue representing important possible alternatives and makes a recommendation that is supported by an analysis of the issues

 

Identifies some important sides of the issue and others that are not relevant and presents a recommendation that is partially supported

Identifies sides of the issue, most or all of which are not relevant and presents a recommendation that is not supported by the analysis of the issues

 

 

Creates an hypothesis

 

 

Makes an insightful and testable hypothesis based on logical reasoning

 

Makes a testable hypothesis

Makes an hypothesis that may be difficult to test

Makes an hypothesis that is not testable

 

 

 

Formulates a position

 

Formulates a well-organized, completely developed position based on the assigned role and presents logical and persuasive arguments

 

Formulates a reasonable position based on the assigned role and presents sound arguments

Formulates a position based on the assigned role and presents questionable arguments

Formulates a position based on the assigned role that is disorganized, difficult to follow and provides little or no support

 

 

 

Presents and defends a position

 

Proposes a realistic and justifiable position; thoroughly explains several strengths and weaknesses of each alternative solution provided by others

Proposes a reasonable position and explains strengths and weaknesses of each alternative solution proposed by others

Proposes a position and explains strengths and weaknesses of some alternatives proposed by others

Proposes an irrelevant position and is unable to identify strengths or weaknesses for solutions proposed by others

 

 

Participates in on-line forum

 

Participates in depth in an on-line forum discussion to effectively present and defend a position; debates the position of others

 

 

Participates in an on-line forum discussion to present and defend a position; debates the position of others

Participates in an on-line forum discussion to present and defend a position that contains errors; may be unable to debate the position of others

Participates in an on-line forum discussion to present a position, but is unable to defend the position nor to debate the position of others

 

             

 

 

Possible extensions